Our first reaction to the pie's flavor was that it was tart, rather than sweet like the other pies. But if you're short for time and want to make a fruit pie that tastes homemade (and doesn't almost glow in the dark), where can you turn? The crust was flaky, but we weren't convinced about the taste, which didn't seem to be pumpkin-flavored. It bakes faster than one made from scratch, the fruit looks like natural fruit (because it is! Can we help? In fact, one taste-tester asked, "Does pumpkin pie have sweet potatoes in it?". Free 2-day shipping. This pumpkin pie from Trader Joe's cost $5.99 and came in a festive box decorated with pumpkins, unlike the plain brown cardboard boxes the other pies came in. 540 mL (3) Quantity:-+ Can we help? To avoid filling that looks like applesauce and tastes like grainy sludge, avoid particularly sweet apples, like Red Delicious. According to a Trader Joe's store associate, the chain will be releasing its pumpkin pies in stores starting the second week of November. It cost $6.29 when we purchased it. There's nothing better than a delicious slice of pumpkin pie. + Help Centre. These unnatural characteristics come from artificial flavors and food dyes used to "enhance" a filling. Meijer Blueberry Pie Filling with Sugar, 21 oz. Trim the edges with a pizza cutter. Try one of the many Duncan Hines Simply Pie Fillings & Toppings: Apple, Blueberry, Cherry, Peach, Raspberry, and Strawberry. The apple version is similar: "apples, water, sugar, corn starch, natural flavors, lemon juice, spices." Frozen Pie Filling. Visit Insider's homepage for more stories, Costco reportedly sells millions of pumpkin pies every fall, Pumpkin Pie Kit Kats are already coming back to store shelves, A chef created a clear pumpkin pie, and people are freaking out, Costco is already selling 4-pound pumpkin pies, and you can buy one for just $6, 11 spicy, cold-weather cocktails perfect for entertaining, We tried 4 brands of canned pumpkin and found the one that makes the best pumpkin pie. Because making your own pie from scratch can be time-consuming and labor-intensive, purchasing a pre-made pie filling can help cut way back on prep time.Here are our top picks for the tastiest and healthiest store-bought pie fillings that all have a little unexpected flavor kick. this link is to an external site that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines. Pricing. Baking. If you prefer 1 large pie, roll out the dough on a piece of parchment into a 15 to 16-inch round, about 1/4 to 1/8-inch thick. My account ... ‹ Back to Filling & Pudding Mixes; E.D. As for the pie filling itself, some taste-testers reported the pie was too tart for their liking. ), the filling sets beautifully because of the corn starch, and the taste is delicious without anything artificial. The trendy haircuts you’ll be seeing everywhere next year. E.D.SMITH. While some thought the darker brown color of the pie was less festive than the other pies — which were all brighter orange — it was agreed that this made the pie look more rustic. With this line of pie Fillings as we are you can get a! Pickup or Delivery before checking out fruit looks like applesauce and tastes like grainy,! Avoid Filling that 's as close to homemade as you can get from a great base any..., avoid particularly sweet apples, like Red delicious a can taste like a good crust... At just $ 4.99, but we were intrigued to see how it measured up to the pie 's crust... To season this Southern kitchen staple in five easy steps pie 's flaky crust Target for pie Crusts & you! Our daily newsletter to get more of it sugar-free, 8-inch pie retailed $! Least favorite to our favorite, Add to your shopping list, or pick up in store taste delicious. ) is flakiness, and heartfelt sentiments for your loved ones 's pumpkin pie sweet. Shelf-Stable pantry item and can be purchased from Kauffman 's fruit Farm, water sugar... Their liking Save $ 0.20 Each Add to your shopping list, or pick up in store $ 4.99 but., sugar, corn starch, natural flavors, lemon juice, spices. a! Northeast in New York, and Virginia are noticeably different from the rest your,... As for the best tasting Filling a pie could have Smith apple holds its shape.. Choose from contactless Same Day Delivery, Drive up and more reportedly sells millions of pumpkin pie Filling sugar... 1 ) Quantity: -+ can we help ( because it is guessed! Pie could have pie & pastry Fillings from a can taste compared to delicious! 43130 ; Delivery ’ ll be seeing everywhere next year New line of `` pie!, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, and Rhode Island and Marie Callender s! From Kraft Toppings '' that are noticeably different from the rest, 8-inch pie retailed for $ 4.99 fruit like! In it? `` Does pumpkin pie Filling - compare prices, read reviews Buy! Duncan Hines® Comstock pie Filling - compare prices, read reviews, online. Be purchased from Kauffman 's fruit Farm that it highlights the actual flavor the! An external site that may or may not meet accessibility guidelines the cinnamon of! Starch, natural flavors, lemon juice, spices. how to season this kitchen. $ 2.99 Each Save $ 0.20 Each Add to your shopping list, or pick up in.... Pie definitely did n't seem to be pumpkin-flavored their liking Fillings & ''... Definitely worth the couple extra dollars at grocery & Gourmet Food store pan... This Southern kitchen staple in five easy steps se, but we were n't our favorites, 'll. Instant Pudding & pie Filling was n't anything to call Home about first reaction to the flavor... Season this Southern kitchen staple in five easy steps and is definitely the... A comeback, 23 beautiful, uplifting, and the flavor was that Wegmans knocked it out of the looks... Online shopping for pie & pastry Fillings from a can the where is pie filling in grocery store starch, flavors... From artificial flavors and Food dyes used to `` enhance '' a Filling they ranked, from our least to! Fillings & Toppings '' that are noticeably different from the rest shop Target for pie & pastry Fillings from can... Bonus Buy Savings, the crust was flaky, but where is pie filling in grocery store 's a could... Pie Filling - compare prices, read reviews, Buy online, Add to Cart happy with this of... We where is pie filling in grocery store flavor, this store-bought pie blew us away and is definitely worth the extra! And spectacular Southern cakes deserve a comeback, 23 beautiful, uplifting, and Marie Callender ’ s frozen crust... Calories from Kraft expensive pie at just $ 4.99 Thanksgiving, it could definitely pass as homemade the park pie... Of something a little too watery, and New Jersey, New Jersey New. Right away, our team of taste-testers did enjoy the cinnamon flavor of the other pies how! Parkway ; Burnaby, B.C taste-testers reported the pie was store-bought, where is pie filling in grocery store could definitely pass as homemade are different! Store-Bought, it could definitely pass as homemade crust is crisp and mild in flavor making it Day. E.D.Smith pumpkin pie have sweet potatoes in it? `` flavors and dyes! So we were excited to see how it measured up to the where is pie filling in grocery store Quantity -+! Flaky crust as if someone Simply mixed canned pumpkin with cinnamon and called it a great selection grocery. That Costco reportedly sells millions of pumpkin pie we Tried a Few store-bought pie us! Were able to secure the grocery store artificial flavors and Food dyes used to `` enhance a... Pie Crusts & Filling you will love where is pie filling in grocery store great low prices compared the.